Best Logger Boots

The best logger boot for loggers and timber work: Thorogood 804-3555

Loggers and timber work need four things from a boot. The shaft has to be tall enough to brace the ankle on side-hill ground. The outsole has to hold on mud, bark and slash. The upper needs a waterproof barrier for wet brush and creek crossings. And the toe needs protection wherever the crew’s rules require it. OSHA’s logging standard, 29 CFR 1910.266, asks for the same things: foot protection such as heavy-duty logging boots that are waterproof or water repellent and that cover and support the ankle. Those demands decide every pick below. The Thorogood 804-3555 meets all four, so it is the one to buy for a crew that works through the year in wet timber.

Get Thorogood 804-3555

Thorogood lists the 804-3555 (Logger Series, 9” Brown Stud Horse Waterproof) with:

Thorogood offers it in sizes 8 to 15 in D and EEE widths. Retail listings price it at about $350-390.

It wins on height and protection together. Its 9-inch shaft is an inch taller than the 8-inch boots on this list, and it has a safety toe. Thorogood lists no insulation, so it suits crews working in spring mud and summer brush, where an insulated boot runs hot. Some crews should skip it. A crew in deep snow should buy the insulated Chippewa below. A worker whose employer does not require a safety toe and who needs a 4E width is better served by the Carolina. Whoever runs the saw needs the HAIX, which is built with chainsaw cut protection. These picks were not tested. The page goes by the makers’ published specifications, and each figure is given as that maker’s.

What decides a logger boot on steep ground and in brush

Height. Work boots usually come in 6-inch, 8-inch and 9-inch shafts. On a cutting slope, the taller shaft gives more leather above the ankle bone to brace against a roll, and it keeps out more slash and snow. Every pick here is listed at 8 or 9 inches. A 6-inch boot is not worth the money for side-hill timber work, even if it is cheaper.

Outsole and heel. A logger boot has a deep rubber outsole and a heel built up under the back of the foot so it digs in going downhill. Chippewa, for example, describes the Vibram outsole and raised logger heel on its Super Logger as giving traction and stability on uneven ground. Calked boots, with steel spikes set into the sole, are a separate class for crews that walk felled logs all day. The rubber-soled boots on this list are for mixed ground: dirt, rock, gravel roads and landings.

Waterproofing. Each pick has a named waterproof layer: a membrane in the Thorogood and Chippewa, UltraDry in the Irish Setter, SCUBALINER in the Carolina and GORE-TEX in the HAIX. Leather that says only “water resistant” is not enough for a day of wet brush.

Toe protection and electrical hazard. ASTM F2413 is the US standard for protective-toe footwear. In its current editions, the I and C marks mean the toe cap passed a 75 foot-pound impact test and a 2,500-pound compression test. An EH mark means the sole and heel withstood 18,000 volts at 60 Hz for one minute in dry conditions. An EH rating is secondary protection only, meant for incidental contact with open circuits of 600 volts or less in dry conditions. It does not make it safe to approach a downed power line. If your employer requires an ASTM F2413 toe, buy only a boot whose maker states that rating.

Cut protection. OSHA requires anyone who runs a chainsaw in logging to wear foot protection made of cut-resistant material that protects against contact with a running chain. A plain leather logger boot does not meet that requirement, however heavy it is. The European chainsaw standard grades boots by chain speed, and Class 2 is tested at 24 metres per second.

Insulation, width and price. Insulation is listed in grams. 400g of 3M Thinsulate, as in the Chippewa, suits cold work standing still, but it is not worth the money for a crew that cuts mostly between April and October. Width matters more than most buyers expect when the foot swells over a ten-hour day: Thorogood offers D and EEE, Irish Setter D and EE, and Carolina D, 2E and 4E. If your work is mostly on flat ground, concrete or a jobsite rather than in timber, a lace-up boot from the best steel-toe work boots list fits the job better.

Winter pick: Chippewa Super Logger SL5405

The Chippewa Super Logger SL5405 is the boot for loggers whose season runs into snow and frozen ground. Chippewa lists the lining as Dri-Lex plus 400g 3M Thinsulate. Its upper is premium waterproof full-grain leather with a breathable waterproof membrane, and its steel toe is marked ASTM F2413 Rated, with an electrical hazard rating as well. The shaft is 9 inches, the same as the Thorogood’s.

Get Chippewa Super Logger SL5405

On the outsole, Chippewa lists the Vibram Tacoma TC4 Plus and says the Vibram outsole and raised logger heel give traction and stability on uneven terrain. That covers the steep-ground demand directly. Sizes run 7 to 15 in E and EEE widths, and Chippewa’s own price is $399.95.

Buy it if you cut through the winter, stand on landings in the cold, or wade snow to reach the stand. It meets every demand the Thorogood meets and adds the 400g insulation. Do not buy it for summer work. On a hot day in the brush, 400 grams of Thinsulate is a cost you carry with no benefit, and the Thorogood is the better boot for that. Chippewa lists it only in E and EEE, and its size guide counts E as a medium width.

Lower-priced safety toe: Irish Setter Mesabi 83834

The Irish Setter Mesabi 83834 is the safety-toe logger boot for a buyer who does not want to pay what the Thorogood or Chippewa cost. Irish Setter’s own price for style 83834 is $204.99. It lists the boot at 8 inches tall, in full-grain waterproof leather with the UltraDry Waterproofing System. The steel toe is rated to ASTM F2413-24, I/C, EH SR. SR stands for slip resisting under ASTM’s slip test for footwear, so the boot meets the toe, electrical hazard and slip marks in one listing.

Get Irish Setter Mesabi 83834

Irish Setter gives the construction as a Goodyear welt and lists the boot as resoleable. The outsole is listed as the Stars and Stripes Logger in black. Sizes run 8 to 15 in Regular (D) and Wide (EE).

Compared with the Thorogood, you give up an inch of shaft height, 8 inches against 9, and the Thorogood’s EEE width. You get a lower maker price and a maker who says plainly that the boot can be resoled, which matters if you expect to wear through more than one outsole. Choose it over the Thorogood if price decides and your ground is not steep enough for the extra inch to matter. Skip it if your foot needs more than an EE width, or if you cut through deep snow. Irish Setter lists no insulation for it, so the Chippewa is the winter boot.

Soft-toe pick for wide feet: Carolina Elm CA8821

The Carolina Elm CA8821 is a soft-toe logger. It is the right boot only for crews whose rules do not call for a protective toe, but for them it does two things the other picks do not. Carolina offers it in D, 2E and 4E, and 4E is the widest fit on this list. At $194.99 on Carolina’s own site, it also has the lowest maker price here. Carolina’s full name for it is “Elm: 8” Waterproof Logger (Soft Toe)”, so the shaft is 8 inches.

Get Carolina Elm CA8821

For waterproofing, Carolina lists its SCUBALINER, which it calls its exclusive proprietary waterproof lining system. Carolina also rates the boot for electrical hazard. It describes this as footwear tested by an independent lab to withstand 18,000 volts at 60 Hz for one minute without leakage. Carolina does not name an ASTM standard for that rating.

The trade-off is the toe. With no steel or composite cap, the Elm meets no ASTM F2413 toe rating. That rules it out on any crew, contract or landing that requires a safety toe, and out of the saw operator’s job entirely. Buy it if you are a land manager, cruiser, fence or brush worker on steep ground who needs height, a waterproof liner and a 4E width. Do not buy it to save money on a job that requires a safety toe. Paying about $10 more for the Irish Setter gets you an F2413 toe.

For whoever runs the saw: HAIX Protector Ultra Lime Green

The HAIX Protector Ultra Lime Green is the pick for the faller or bucker who runs the chainsaw. It is the only boot on this list built with chainsaw cut protection. HAIX places the cut-resistant layer in the front half of the boot, to protect the top of the foot and the front of the leg, and says it allows more reaction time if the boot comes in contact with a running chainsaw blade. HAIX North America lists Class 2 chainsaw protection under the European standard, which is tested at a chain speed of 24 m/s. Its certifications are ASTM F 2413, CAN/CSA-Z195 and European Class 2, with a steel safety toe. HAIX also lists non-metallic puncture protection, a slip-resistant Vibram sole (the VIBRAM 050), a GORE-TEX inner liner and two-zone lacing.

Get HAIX Protector Ultra Lime Green

HAIX North America lists the boot as EH rated to 18 kV. That is the test voltage of an electrical hazard rating, which is secondary protection for incidental contact with open circuits of 600 volts or less in dry conditions, not protection against a downed power line. It lists the boot height as 8 inches, says the boot supports the ankle, and describes a leg cuff that keeps out debris. HAIX offers it in Medium and Wide widths. HAIX says it uses more visible colors on its cut-protective boots to offer more visibility in the environment.

Of the five picks, only this boot has a layer of cut-resistant material, which HAIX says offers added reaction time if you come in contact with the chainsaw blade. If you run the saw, it is the boot to buy, whatever the others cost. If you only set chokers, skid, or work the landing, its cut protection adds a feature you will not use, and the Thorogood gives you a taller 9-inch shaft. HAIX North America lists this model (Prod. no. 603110) with the ASTM F 2413 rating.

The five logger boots side by side

The table below sets out what each maker lists for each pick.

BootHeightToeWaterproofingInsulationWidths
Thorogood 804-35559 inSteel, ASTM F2413-18, EHWaterproof membraneNone listedD, EEE
Chippewa Super Logger SL54059 inSteel, ASTM F2413, EHWaterproof membrane400g 3M ThinsulateE, EEE
Irish Setter Mesabi 838348 inSteel, ASTM F2413-24 I/C EH SRUltraDryNone listedD, EE
Carolina Elm CA88218 inSoft toe, EHSCUBALINERNone listedD, 2E, 4E
HAIX Protector Ultra Lime Green8 inSteel, ASTM F 2413, Class 2 cutGORE-TEXNone listedMedium, Wide

The makers’ published prices are $399.95 for the Chippewa, $204.99 for the Irish Setter and $194.99 for the Carolina. Retail listings put the Thorogood at about $350-390. Read the table by job. A year-round safety-toe crew buys the Thorogood. A winter crew buys the Chippewa. A buyer who wants a safety toe for less buys the Irish Setter. A soft-toe crew with wide feet buys the Carolina. The saw operator buys the HAIX.

A logger boot is built to be laced high and tight. A boot that fits in the store can pinch once your feet swell over a long shift on a slope, so try boots on late in the day, wearing the socks you work in. If your foot sits between two widths, the wider one usually lasts the day better. Of these makers, Irish Setter is the only one that says outright its boot can be resoled, which matters if you plan to keep one pair through several seasons.

FAQ

Do loggers have to wear chainsaw boots?

OSHA’s logging standard, 29 CFR 1910.266, requires every worker who operates a chainsaw to wear foot protection made of cut-resistant material that protects against contact with a running chain. The rest of a logging crew needs waterproof or water-repellent boots that cover and support the ankle, but not cut protection. On this list, only the HAIX Protector Ultra Lime Green is built for the saw operator.

Is a 9-inch logger boot better than an 8-inch one?

The 9-inch shaft on the Thorogood 804-3555 and the Chippewa Super Logger SL5405 puts another inch of leather above the ankle, which helps on side-hill ground and in snow or slash. An 8-inch boot such as the Irish Setter Mesabi 83834 still covers and supports the ankle, as OSHA’s logging rule asks. Pick the height after you have the toe protection, waterproofing and width you need, not before.

Can I wear a soft-toe logger boot for timber work?

Only where your employer or contract does not require a protective toe. The Carolina Elm CA8821 is a soft-toe boot with an electrical hazard rating, but it meets no ASTM F2413 toe rating. On a crew that requires a safety toe, buy a boot whose maker lists F2413, such as the Irish Setter Mesabi 83834 or the Thorogood 804-3555.