Best Work Shorts

Top pick for hot jobs: Carhartt Force Ripstop Cargo Short 107330

For outdoor work in the heat, buy the Carhartt Force Ripstop Cargo Short 107330. Carhartt makes it from 6-ounce stretch ripstop that is 95% nylon and 5% spandex, with FastDry sweat-wicking, UPF 50+ sun protection and a 10-inch inseam.

Get Carhartt Force Ripstop Cargo Short 107330

All five shorts on this list are ranked on the same six things: fabric fiber and weight, stretch, the durability features the maker lists, the pocket layout (including somewhere to carry tools), inseam length and the maker’s own price. None of these shorts was tested for this list. The ranking comes from the makers’ specifications. On those numbers the Carhartt comes first for heat. Its 6-ounce fabric is the lightest weight any maker on this list publishes. The Dickies shorts are 7.25 oz and 8.5 oz, Duluth lists 8 oz, and Wrangler lists 10 oz. It is also the only pick whose maker lists all three of these: elastane stretch, a sweat-wicking treatment and a UPF rating. UPF 50 means the fabric lets through no more than 1/50 of UV radiation, about 2%. That matters on legs that are bare from the knee down all day.

For tools, Carhartt lists a secure zippered pocket, side cargo pockets with hidden hook-and-loop closures that it calls ideal for small tools and accessories, and front slash pockets. Carhartt describes the fit as relaxed: mid-rise, sitting just below the waist, with room in the seat and thigh. The comfort flex waistband and sewn-on-seam belt loops are listed as standard.

Carhartt’s own listing puts it at about $60-65, depending on colour and size. Carhartt’s guarantee says that if a product fails to meet your expectations, it will work to make it right through repair, replacement or credit. Its repair service covers buttons, snaps, closures and zippers, and Carhartt says a reasonable charge may apply when the damage is normal wear and tear.

Who should not buy it:

The five shorts on their makers’ figures

Every figure below comes from the maker’s own product page for that exact model. Where a maker publishes nothing on a point, the line says so.

Two points in that list decide more than they seem to.

Stretch. Only two makers list elastane (spandex): Carhartt at 5% and Duluth at 3%. Wrangler lists 100% cotton ripstop with no stretch. Dickies calls the WR852 fabric “mechanical stretch” and lists FLEX fabric “for comfort and ease of movement”. Its stated blend is polyester and cotton only.

Fabric weight. US fabric weights are given in ounces per square yard. The 42283’s 8.5 oz twill carries about 42% more fabric per square yard than the Carhartt’s 6 oz ripstop (8.5 ÷ 6 = 1.42). In heat you feel that difference at every step.

Duluth Trading DuluthFlex Fire Hose Cargo Shorts: for cotton canvas and tool straps

Buy the Duluth Trading DuluthFlex Fire Hose Cargo Shorts (item 36333) instead of the Carhartt if you want cotton canvas and a dedicated place for a utility knife. Duluth builds them from 97% cotton / 3% spandex DuluthFlex Fire Hose fabric. It describes the canvas as flexible and highly abrasion-resistant and headlines it as “30% Lighter”.

Get Duluth Trading DuluthFlex Fire Hose Cargo Shorts

The pocket layout is why this short wins for trades that carry a blade and a tape. Duluth lists in-or-out tuckable 3-in-1 cargo pockets, so the flap can sit outside or be tucked away. It also lists utility straps sized for a box cutter or tape measure. For movement, Duluth lists its Crouch Gusset, an extra fabric panel at the crotch for room when you squat. The seams are triple-stitched.

The fit is relaxed with an 11-inch inseam.

The trade-off is heat. This is cotton canvas, and cotton takes up more sweat than nylon or polyester. If your days are spent on a roof or in direct sun, the Carhartt’s nylon, wicking and UPF figures suit the job better. If you move between an air-conditioned shop and short outdoor stints, the Duluth’s tool straps are worth more than those numbers.

Duluth sells under its No Bull Guarantee. Duluth says that after one year it will also consider returns for items that are defective or don’t perform as designed, and that the guarantee covers product flaws and failures, not ordinary wear and tear. The product page shows today’s price.

Wrangler RIGGS Workwear Ripstop Ranger Cargo Short 3W360: for tape-measure users at a middle price

Buy the Wrangler RIGGS Workwear Ripstop Ranger Cargo Short 3W360 if you carry a clip-on tape measure and want cargo storage for less than the Carhartt or Duluth. Wrangler lists it at $39.99 in 100% cotton ripstop, with a relaxed fit and a 12 1/2-inch inseam.

Get Wrangler RIGGS Workwear Ripstop Ranger Cargo Short 3W360

The feature that sets it apart is Wrangler’s tape-measure reinforcement. Wrangler lists this reinforcement as a feature of the 3W360. None of the other four makers lists reinforcement at that spot. Wrangler also lists side cargo pockets with flaps and concealed snaps. Wrangler names an action gusset for movement.

Who should buy something else:

Stock varies by colour on Wrangler’s own page. When a colour shows sold out, Wrangler offers a notify-when-back option, and the model stays listed. If your colour is out, check another.

Dickies FLEX Relaxed Fit Work Shorts WR852: the low-cost stretch short

Buy the Dickies FLEX Relaxed Fit Work Shorts WR852 if your budget is tight or your job wants a plain work-short look rather than cargo pockets. Dickies lists them at $24.99, in waists 30 to 44 and five colours. That is the lowest maker price on this list.

Get Dickies FLEX Relaxed Fit Work Shorts WR852

Dickies makes the WR852 from 7.25 oz mechanical stretch twill, 65% polyester / 35% cotton. It lists an easy-care stain release finish, a wrinkle-resistant design and moisture-wicking technology. The relaxed fit sits slightly below the waist with extra room in the seat and thighs. The 11-inch inseam hits just above the knee. For storage, Dickies lists a cell phone pocket within easy reach plus additional pockets for work items. It does not describe a cargo pocket or tool straps.

That pocket layout sets the limit. A plumber or electrician who carries a knife, a pencil, a tape and fasteners on the body runs out of room here. In that case the Wrangler 3W360’s cargo pockets cost $15 more on the makers’ prices, which is the better spend. For shop, warehouse, delivery or maintenance work, where tools live on a cart or belt, the WR852 covers what you need for the least money.

Two more limits:

Dickies Loose Fit Flat Front Work Shorts 42283: for the longest inseam and uniform programs

Buy the Dickies Loose Fit Flat Front Work Shorts 42283 if you need knee coverage, a large waist or a short that passes for uniform wear. Dickies lists it at $27.99, in waists 28 to 60 and ten colours. That is the widest size and colour range on the makers’ pages for any pick here.

Get Dickies Loose Fit Flat Front Work Shorts 42283

Dickies makes it from 8.5 oz heavyweight twill, 65% polyester / 35% cotton. Its 13-inch inseam is the longest on this list, and Dickies says it skims the knee. The fit sits at the waist and is roomier in the seat and thigh. Dickies’ product copy lists an easy-care stain-release finish, wrinkle resistance, a flat-front permanent crease, a multi-use pocket on the right leg and long tunnel belt loops that Dickies says have heavy-duty tool belts covered. The multi-use leg pocket is the utility pocket here.

The 13-inch length is the deciding figure. Compared with Carhartt’s 10-inch inseam, it adds 3 inches of fabric over the lower thigh. That helps when you kneel briefly on rough surfaces and when a site supervisor objects to shorts that ride well above the knee. The heavy-duty belt loops matter if you hang a loaded nail bag at the waist rather than carrying tools in pockets.

What is not worth the money: buying the 42283 just for heat. At 8.5 oz it is heavier than every pick here except the 10 oz Wrangler 3W360, and Dickies lists no stretch fiber or wicking finish for it. If you don’t need the 13-inch length, waists past 44 or the belt loops, the $24.99 WR852 is lighter at 7.25 oz and adds a moisture-wicking finish for less money.

Fabric, inseam and site rules: what decides the right pair

Fiber. Of these five, Carhartt alone lists a nylon-based fabric (95%), and it pairs it with a sweat-wicking treatment. The two Dickies shorts are 65% polyester, and only the WR852 lists a moisture-wicking finish. Duluth and Wrangler use cotton-based canvas and ripstop, which feel softer but hold more sweat. In steady sun, pick by the wicking claim and the ounce weight. For shop work with breaks indoors, the fiber matters less than the pockets.

Stretch. Elastane content is the published figure to check: 5% in the Carhartt, 3% in the Duluth, none listed in the Wrangler. Dickies lists the WR852 as “Mechanical Stretch Twill” with no elastane in its stated blend. A gusset (Duluth’s Crouch Gusset, Wrangler’s action gusset) adds room at the crotch whatever the fabric, and makes the biggest difference on a no-elastane short like the 3W360.

Inseam. The five picks span 10 to 13 inches. Dickies says its 11-inch WR852 hits just above the knee and its 13-inch 42283 skims the knee. Where the hem actually lands depends on your height and on the rise, meaning how high the waistband sits. Two shorts with the same inseam can end at different points if one sits at the waist and the other below it.

Flame and arc hazards. None of these five makers lists a flame-resistant rating such as NFPA 2112 or an arc rating for NFPA 70E work. They are not for welding, torch cutting or energized electrical work. Those jobs need FR-rated garments, and most shops that do them require long pants anyway.

When shorts are not enough. Shorts lower the heat load on your legs only. If you are still overheating on a roof or slab in midsummer, the next purchase is something that cools your torso. See the best cooling vests for construction for evaporative and phase-change options that work alongside any of these shorts.

FAQ

Are nylon ripstop work shorts cooler than cotton canvas ones?

The makers’ figures point that way for these picks. Carhartt’s 107330 is 6 oz, 95% nylon fabric with FastDry sweat-wicking. Duluth’s 36333 is 97% cotton canvas, and Wrangler’s 3W360 is 10 oz, 100% cotton ripstop with no wicking claim. Cotton absorbs more sweat than nylon, so in direct sun the nylon short is the better choice.

Which inseam length should I buy for work shorts?

The picks here run from 10 inches (Carhartt 107330) through 11 inches (Duluth 36333, Dickies WR852) and 12 1/2 inches (Wrangler 3W360) to 13 inches (Dickies 42283). Buy the 13-inch length if you kneel often or your site discourages shorts above the knee. Otherwise, 10 or 11 inches leaves more of the leg bare for cooling. Rise changes where the hem lands, so a short that sits below the waist ends lower than one with the same inseam that sits at the waist.

Can I wear these work shorts for welding or electrical work?

No. None of these five makers lists a flame-resistant rating such as NFPA 2112 or an arc rating for NFPA 70E work on these models. The Carhartt’s nylon and the Dickies’ polyester blends can melt when sparks or spatter hit them. Hot work and energized electrical work need FR-rated clothing, usually long pants.